| Aaryn Parks | National Christian Academy | 2020 | Oklahoma University (football) | |
| Curtis Jacobs | McDonogh | 2020 | Penn State University (football) | |
| Luke Eberle | AACS | 2020 | Liberty University (soccer) | |
| Tyler Clark | Spalding | 2020 | Centenary College | |
| Sammy Carter | Indian Creek | 2020 | Rhodes College (Lacrosse) | |
| Ryan Saunderson | Reservoir | 2020 | University of Maryland | |
| Roman Hinds | Gilman | 2020 | Swarthmore College | |
| Michael Parme | St. Mary's | 2020 | Bard College | |
| Marcus Mitchell | Wilde Lake | 2020 | Olympus Prep | |
| Logan Vican | Broadneck | 2020 | Millersville University | |
| Kendall Walker | Boys' Latin | 2020 | Morehouse U | |
| Justin Hendricks | Howard | 2020 | | |
| Jordan Oates | Atholton | 2020 | Salisbury University | |
| Jared Archer | Boys' Latin | 2020 | Elizabethtown University | |
| Jake Goodman | Severna Park | 2020 | Juniata College | |
| Jack McGaha | Oakdale | 2020 | Washington College | |
| Ian Swartz | Atholton | 2020 | Towson University | |
| DJ Hopkins | Oakland Mills | 2020 | Morgan State University | |
| Cam Brown | Perkiomon Prep | 2020 | Perkiomon Prep | |
| Cam Sapienza | Mount Saint Joseph | 2020 | Stevenson University | |
| Bryce Meads | John Carroll | 2020 | Juniata College | |
| Brendan Davis | Broadneck | 2020 | UMBC | |
| Tristan Kent | Liberty | 2019 | York College | |
| Chase Kirkland | Friends | 2019 | Maryland | |
| Patrick Devitt | St. Mary's | 2019 | Washington College | |
| AJ Burch | Severn | 2019 | St. Francis - PA | |
| Justin Williams | | 2017 | William & Mary | |
| Jared Robinson | Mount Saint Joseph | 2017 | Georgetown | |
| Jihar Willaims | Friends | 2017 | William and Mary | |
| Isaiah Burnett | GCS | 2017 | Navy | |
| Emmitt Davis | Broadneck | 2016 | Navy (football) | |
| Kahlil Richards | New Town | 2016 | Siena | |
| Justin Gorham | Calvert Hall | 2016 | Towson | |
| Bruce Moore | McDonough | 2016 | Bucknell | |
| Sam Allen | Harrisburg | 2016 | Hobart | |
| Donte Doleman | Goretti | 2016 | David & Elkins | |
| Justin Kane | Spalding | 2016 | Coast Guard Academy | |
| Nate Eberley | AACS | 2016 | Messiah College | |
| Ben Toung | Kent Island | 2016 | Stevenson | |
| Mike Riley | Frederick | 2016 | Hood College | |
| Jordan Jones | Poly | 2016 | Charleston Southern | |
| Darick Kerns | Cumberland | 2016 | St. Mary's | |
| Drew Edwards | Calvert Hall | 2015 | Providence | |
| Bryce Thurston | Monte Verde (Fl) Prep Team | 2015 | Mount Saint Mary’s | |
| Darryl Williams | Glenelg Country (Ellicott City, Md.) | 2015 | Randolph Macon | |
| TJ Duckett | Calvert Hall | 2015 | Lycoming | |
| Lawrence Cager | Calvert Hall | 2015 | Miami Hurricanes (Football) | |
| James Foley | Annapolis Area Christian School | 2015 | | |
| Ameka Akaya | St. Maria Goretti | 2015 | | |
| David Huber | Hampton | 2015 | | |
| Evan Phoenix | Calvert Hall | 2015 | Central Connecticut State University | |
| Evan Fisher | McDonough | 2015 | Sienna | |
| Alex Davis
| Severna Park | 2014 | | |
| Boris Rajovic | Glenelg Country | 2014 | | |
| Chancellor Barnard | Glenelg Country | 2014 | Loyola - Md. | South Bat Lakers (G-League) |
| Collin Luther | Hampton (Pa.) | 2014 | Elon | |
| Derron Morgan | Indian Creek | 2014 | | |
| Graham Seering | Mount St. Joseph | 2014 | | |
| Herandre Fair-Curry | Eleanor Roosevelt | 2014 | | |
| James Soderlund | Severn | 2014 | | |
| Joe Kearney | Mount St. Joseph | 2014 | | |
| Kyle Doran | Mount St. Joseph | 2014 | Johns Hopkins | |
| Matt Harding | Archbishop Spalding | 2014 | Princeton (baseball) | |
| Michael Bernetti | Atholton | 2014 | | |
| Ryan Luther | Hampton (Pa.) | 2014 | Pittsburgh | |
| Ryland Collier | Severn | 2014 | | |
| Zander Wear | Mount St. Joseph | 2014 | Hamilton | |
| Allen Jackson | McDonogh | 2012 | Duke (Football) | |
| Ben Mortimer | Queen Anne | 2012 | | |
| Chase Cormier | Milford Mill | 2012 | Grambling State | |
| Cole Bailey | Severn | 2011 | Tufts (Lacrosse) | |
| Conner Lipinski | AACS | 2012 | Maryland | |
| Daniel Gregory | Old Mill | 2012 | Coastal Bend JC | |
| Darnell Solomon | Broadneck | 2012 | | |
| Grant Harris | AACS | 2012 | | |
| Greg Brown | Spalding | 2012 | St. Francis - Pa. | Campo Mourao (Brazil) |
| Josh Chiasson | St. Mary's | 2012 | Lehigh (Football) | |
| Marc Burton | Severn | 2012 | High Point | |
| Matt Franchak | Spalding | 2012 | St. Joseph (Lacrosse) | |
| Max Siegrist | Severn | 2012 | Kenyon | |
| Phil Lawrence | Mount St. Joseph | 2012 | Marist | St. Vincent & Genedines (Spain) |
| Tanner Brooks | St. Paul's | 2012 | Skidmore | Neptune (Ireland) |
| Wes Brown | Good Counsel | 2012 | Maryland (Football) | |
| Bobby Bates | Broadneck | 2011 | Frostburg State | |
| David Windsor | Mount St. Joseph | 2011 | Seton Hill | |
| Four McGlynn | Dallstown Area (Pa.) | 2011 | Towson | |
| Garrett Snoops | Spalding | 2011 | Marymount | |
| Kelby Johnson | Dematha | 2011 | Virginia (Football) | |
| Mike Wilde | St. Mary's | 2011 | William & Mary (Club) | |
| Miles Code | St. Paul's | 2011 | | |
| Nigel Sydnor | St. Paul's | 2011 | NJIT | |
| Phillip Perry | AACS | 2011 | McDaniel | |
| Robbie Weingart | McDonogh | 2011 | Denison | |
| Rokas Cesnulevicius | Hawaii Prep | 2011 | Evansville | |
| Ryan Griffin | Glenelg | 2011 | DeSales | |
| Taylor Hurst | St. Mary's | 2011 | Alabama | |
| Tre Duncan | Severn | 2011 | High Point | |
| Tyler Lewis | AACS | 2011 | Eastern | |
| Andrew Adams | Severn | 2010 | Alleghany College | |
| Brian Bieman | Severn | 2010 | Lehigh | |
| Chris Capella | Severna Park | 2010 | | |
| David Clyde | Glen Burnie | 2010 | | |
| David Deavers | Glen Burnie | 2010 | | |
| Dylon Cormier | Cardinal Gibbons | 2010 | Loyola | |
| Evan Lipinski | McDonogh | 2010 | Maryland | |
| Julian Herrell | Good Counsel | 2010 | Bowie State | |
| Kam Tower | St. Mary's | 2010 | LSU | |
| Marcus Snipes | Meade | 2010 | Richmond (Football) | |
| Marquel Pratt | Old Mill | 2010 | | |
| Marvin Salmond | Old Mill | 2010 | | |
| Matt Miller | Mount St. Joseph | 2010 | New Hampshire | |
| Michael Holly | Old Mill | 2010 | Millersville | |
| Ryley Beaumont | Mount St. Joseph | 2010 | Elon | |
| Walter Noel | St. Paul's | 2010 | St. Johns | |
| Winfield Willis | St. Paul's | 2010 | NJIT | |
| Zack Scantlin | AACS | 2010 | Stevenson | |
| Alex Testoff | Severn | 2009 | Ohio State | |
| Andrew Sterritt | Gonzaga | 2009 | Boston College | |
| Anthony Butler | Annapolis | 2009 | West Chester | |
| Ben Montgomery | Severn | 2009 | MIT | |
| Brendan Bald | Severna Park | 2009 | Vermont | |
| Brian Eads | Howard | 2009 | BYU | |
| Danny Murphy | Glen Burnie | 2009 | Stevenson | |
| Doug Howard | Flint Hill (Va.) | 2009 | William & Mary | |
| Jesse Martin | Howard | 2009 | Marist | |
| Jimmy Gibbons | Southern | 2009 | | |
| Jordan Fess | North County | 2009 | | |
| Kevin Marshall | Severna Park | 2009 | | |
| Leron Eaddy | River Hill | 2009 | Central Michigan (Football) | |
| Malcolm Sizer | Towson Catholic | 2009 | | |
| Mark Bennett | | 2009 | Wheaton | |
| Marques Lowe | Severna Park | 2009 | | |
| Matt Gierl | AACS | 2009 | Palm Beach Atlantic | |
| Matt Heacock | Loyola | 2009 | Salisbury (Football) | |
| Matt Rum | Loyola | 2009 | William & Mary | Heba A1 (Greece) |
| Mike Campanaro | River Hill | 2009 | Wake Forest (Football) | Baltimore Ravens |
| Nick Groce | St. Mary's | 2009 | UMBC | |
| Patrick Lipinski | AACS | 2009 | Trinity Intl. Chicago | |
| Ronnie Hoffman | St. Mary's | 2009 | Jacksonville (Lacrosse) | |
| Sidney Mcray | St. Paul's | 2009 | Shepherd | |
| Terrance Boyd | Norman (Okla.) | 2009 | Central Colo. State | |
| Trey Quinn | St. Mary's | 2009 | Hood College | |
| Tyler Rudd | Glen Burnie | 2009 | McDaniel | |
| Tyler Thurston | Severn | 2009 | Catholic U | |
| Anthony Armstead | Mount St. Joseph | 2008 | Seton Hill (Football) | |
| Dave Bennett | | 2008 | UMBC | |
| Josh Danza | Spalding | 2008 | Stevenson | |
| Kevin Hunt | Broadneck | 2008 | Anne Arundel CC | |
| Marvin Smith | Severn | 2008 | Valley Forge | |
| Perry Wright | Cardinal Gibbons | 2008 | Widener | |
| Quinton Jones | Mount St. Joseph | 2008 | UMBC | |
